14 caterers in Key West, FL
We tracked down 21 possible caterers around Key West and Marathon, Islamorada, Key Largo, Tavernier, then checked each one against its own website. These are the 14 we could verify. Not a top ten, and not a paid directory.
3 of them (21%) publish their pricing. Those are listed first with the real numbers. The other 11 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.
Know a Key West catererwe're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it.
Florida wedding caterers typically charge $35 to $60 per guest, with the broader market ranging from $20 to $300 per guest. Because premium and luxury caterers rarely publish prices and require a direct inquiry, the vendors reflected in these numbers skew toward the more affordable end, meaning the true market average is likely higher.
The Key West caterers list
A Dinner in Paradise
MarathonA Dinner in Paradise is a personal chef service in the Florida Keys offering customized 4-course meals prepared and served in your home, resort, or vacation rental. Chef Arthur handles menu creation, shopping, cooking, and cleanup for intimate gatherings.
from $95/guestCuisine: contemporary american, seafood, ocean-to-table +1Service: plated, custom multi-courseBar service: NoPer-guest catering pricing starting at $95/person with a $375 minimum; groceries charged separately.
upscaleelegantpersonalizedocean-to-tablefresh localDestination Catering & Events
Key WestDestination Catering & Events is a full-service Caribbean caterer in Key West specializing in on-site cooking for weddings and events throughout the Florida Keys. They offer customized menus featuring fresh, flame-cooked island-inspired cuisine prepared in a mobile commercial kitchen at your venue.
from $65/guestCuisine: caribbean, island-inspired, seafood +3Service: buffet, plated, food stations +4Bar service: YesWedding catering per-person pricing starting at $65/guest, subject to tax and service charge.
tropicalCaribbeanislandelegantromanticbeachfrontKey West Catering Company
Key WestKey West Catering Company is a chef-driven full-service caterer specializing in wedding catering with customizable plated, buffet, and themed menus. They also offer comprehensive event coordination including florals, décor, venues, and transportation.
$75/guest – $100/guestCuisine: mediterranean, italian, caribbean +4Service: plated, buffetBar service: YesPer-person pricing for plated, buffet, and themed wedding menus; complete package add-on also quoted per person.
elegantupscalerefinedchef-drivencustomizableCaribbean Catering
IslamoradaCaribbean Catering and Rentals is a wedding catering specialist in Islamorada, Florida with over two decades of experience creating custom wedding menus. They offer exceptional catering services focused on personalized dietary needs and event planning.
Pricing on requestCuisine: caribbeanWedding catering pricing available by request only; no published rates provided.
CaribbeanChef Drew's Island Catering
IslamoradaChef Drew's Island Catering is a full-service catering company specializing in custom-designed menus for weddings and private events in the Florida Keys. They offer chef-prepared cuisine ranging from fine dining to casual themed packages with on-site cooking.
Pricing on requestCuisine: contemporary american, seafood, caribbean +4Service: plated, food stations, carving stations +1Bar service: NoWedding catering pricing is by inquiry; per-guest and chef flat-fee structure described but no dollar amounts published.
elegantupscaletropicalgourmetlocally-sourcedinteractive diningGreat Events Catering
Key WestGreat Events Catering is a premier Key West wedding caterer with over 40 years of combined experience, known for customized gourmet menus featuring fresh, local ingredients and flawless execution.
Pricing on requestService: plated, buffet, food stations +2elegantgourmetupscaleislandlocalKey Largo Conch House
Key LargoKey Largo Conch House is a second-generation family-owned seafood restaurant and wedding caterer serving the Florida Keys with fresh local ingredients and customizable menus. They have catered 2000+ Florida Keys weddings with onsite cooking and flexible service styles.
Pricing on requestCuisine: seafood, florida keys cuisineService: buffet, food stations, plated dinners +2Bar service: Yescoastalseafood-focusedcasual-elegantdestination-weddinglocally-sourcedClouds in my Coffee Catering/Private Chef/The Table
MarathonClouds in my Coffee Catering is a fine dining caterer and private chef service in Marathon, Florida, specializing in gourmet cuisine with Italian and Caribbean influences. They offer full-service catering for weddings, cocktail parties, and intimate dinners with customizable menus.
Pricing on requestCuisine: italian, caribbean, mediterranean +1Service: plated, party trays, custom-tailored +1Pricing text contains only deposit and advance notice requirements with no published prices.
elegantgourmetItalianCaribbeanfine diningItalian Food Company
Key LargoItalian Food Company is an authentic Italian caterer and private event venue with locations in Key Largo and Islamorada, specializing in Neapolitan and Roman cuisine, fresh pastas, and wood-fired pizza. They offer full-service catering and stunning venue spaces for weddings, rehearsal dinners, and milestone celebrations.
Pricing on requestCuisine: italian (neapolitan, roman, regional italian)Service: family-style, plated, wood-fired pizza service +1ItalianelegantromanticgardencoastalauthenticSmall Chef At Large Catering
Key WestSmall Chef At Large is a full-service catering company in Key West specializing in gourmet cuisine for private events including dinners, brunches, and cocktail parties. Chef Jennifer Cornell offers customized menus featuring Caribbean and seafood-focused cuisine with options for venues including homes, vacation properties, and yachts.
Pricing on requestCuisine: caribbean, seafood, cuban +3Service: plated, multi-course, passed hors d'oeuvres +2Bar service: YeseleganttropicalcoastalgourmetupscaleCaribbeanimpeccably gourmet catered
MarathonImpeccably Gourmet Catering is a personal chef and catering service in Marathon, Florida specializing in fresh, locally-sourced gourmet cuisine. They offer fully customizable menus for weddings and events of all sizes.
Pricing on requestCuisine: gourmet contemporary, seafood, florida regionalService: plated, customizableBar service: NoWedding catering pricing available by request only; no published rates provided.
elegantgourmetfreshlocally-sourcedcontemporaryCapt Craig's Restaurant
TavernierCaptain Craig's Restaurant is a legendary Florida Keys seafood establishment that offers full-service catering for events of all sizes, including wedding receptions. They specialize in fresh local seafood and their famous fish sandwich, bringing authentic Keys cuisine to your event.
Pricing on requestCuisine: seafood, sandwiches, florida keys regionalBar service: Yescasualcoastalseafood-focusedtropicalIrie Island Eats
MarathonIrie Island Eats is a tropical garden restaurant and catering company in Marathon, Florida Keys, offering fresh, made-from-scratch cuisine for events. They provide catering services with pickup options and specialize in island-inspired flavors.
Pricing on requestCuisine: tropical, seafood, bbq +5Bar service: NotropicalgardencasualislandoutdoorOne Love Food Truck
Key WestOne Love Food Truck offers Caribbean-fusion gourmet catering and personal chef services in Key West, Florida. Chef Clive Thompson brings fine-dining experience to casual island-inspired cuisine for events and celebrations.
Pricing on requestCuisine: caribbean, jamaican, key west fusion +2Service: food trucks, catering, party platters +1Bar service: NoIndividual food truck menu items ($5–$25); party platter pricing by inquiry only.
casualtropicalislandfusiongourmetCaribbean
Which of these 14 fit your budget?
Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.
Rank these for me