32 cake makers in Jacksonville, FL

We tracked down 61 possible cake makers around Jacksonville and St. Augustine, Fernandina Beach, Green Cove Springs, Jacksonville Beach, Yulee, then checked each one against its own website. These are the 32 we could verify. Not a top ten, and not a paid directory.

12 of them (38%) publish their pricing. Those are listed first with the real numbers. The other 20 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.

Know a Jacksonville cake makerwe're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it.

Wedding Cakes pricing in Florida
Typical per-serving range
$7/serving$9/serving
Market range
$3/serving$47/serving
Publish pricing
51of 618

Florida wedding cake bakers typically charge $7 to $9 per serving, with the full market ranging from $3 to $47 per serving. Because premium and luxury bakers rarely publish prices and instead require direct inquiry, this data reflects only vendors who disclose pricing publicly, meaning the true market average is likely higher.

The Jacksonville cake makers list

Showing 20 of 32 cake makers
  • Taylor'd Flair

    Jacksonville

    Taylor'd Flair is a Jacksonville-based custom cake and event design bakery specializing in wedding cakes, celebration cakes, and coordinated dessert treats. They offer custom wedding cakes starting at $8 per serving with multiple flavor options and design flexibility.

    from $8/serving

    Wedding cake pricing by per-serving rate and tiered package minimums; coordinated treats priced per dozen.

    custommodernversatile
  • Sweet Tiffany’s LLC

    St. Augustine

    Sweet Tiffany's is an elite cake studio in Saint Johns/Saint Augustine, Florida specializing in custom epicurean wedding cakes and groom's cakes with handmade designs and unique flavor combinations. Every cake is individually crafted from scratch using fresh ingredients.

    $6/serving – $7/serving

    Per-serving pricing for wedding cakes and groom's cakes with buttercream or fondant options.

    elegantcustomrefinedartisticsophisticated
    sweettiffanys.net77051985047 Fellbrook Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32095, USA
  • Sweets By Staci

    Jacksonville

    Sweets By Staci is a custom wedding cake and dessert table designer based in Jacksonville, FL, specializing in buttercream and fondant cakes with a variety of flavors and fillings. The owner, Staci Glover, is a self-taught cake designer who has been creating custom cakes since 2008.

    $6/serving – $8/serving

    Wedding cake pricing by per-serving rate for buttercream and fondant designs.

    sweetsbystaci.com(904) 254-6394US-1, Jacksonville, FL 32219, USA
  • A Will and A Whisk Bakery

    Fernandina Beach

    A Will and A Whisk is a custom bespoke bakery on Amelia Island specializing in handcrafted cakes, pastries, and desserts tailored to individual taste and style. The owner, Danielle, brings professional pastry experience from Disney and fine dining backgrounds.

    $4/serving – $6/serving

    Retail pie and cheesecake pricing; custom wedding cake pricing by inquiry only.

    customelegantartisanalhandcraftedbespoke
    awillandawhiskbakery.com(904) 799-39871853 S 8th St Ste B, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034, USA
  • Sweet Cravings by Shar

    Green Cove Springs

    Sweet Cravings by Shar is a custom cake and dessert bakery offering personalized cakes, cupcakes, pies, and specialty desserts for weddings and special events. They provide full catering services and dessert tables for weddings, proposals, and celebrations.

    $4/serving – $10/serving

    Cake and dessert vendor offering per-serving pricing for cakes and specialty items, plus catering services starting at $5.00 per guest.

    customartisanhandmade
    sweetcravingsbyshar.com9047885538155 Fountains Way, Suite 3 Saint Johns United States
  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Jacksonville Beach

    Nothing Bundt Cakes is a specialized cake bakery offering customizable Bundt cakes in multiple sizes and flavors, perfect for wedding celebrations. They provide tiered cakes, delivery, and catering services for events.

    $40/serving – $43/serving

    Individual Bundtinis retail pricing; wedding cake pricing requires location selection and inquiry.

    modernelegantcustomizablecontemporary
    nothingbundtcakes.com(904) 677-411213470-3 Beach Boulevard , Jacksonville, FL, 32224
  • Sweet Theory Baking Co.

    Jacksonville

    Sweet Theory Baking Co. is a Jacksonville-based custom cake and cupcake bakery specializing in fresh, made-to-order 3-layer cakes with creative flavor combinations and dietary accommodations. They offer custom and specialty cakes suitable for weddings and special occasions.

    $3/serving – $11/serving

    Retail cake pricing by size with per-serving calculations; no wedding packages or wedding-specific pricing stated.

    artisanalorganiccustommodernplayful
    sweettheorybakingco.com(904) 387-10011243 King St, Jacksonville, FL 32204, USA
  • Alms + Fare

    St. Augustine

    Alms + Fare is a gluten-free and dairy-free wellness bakery in St. Augustine specializing in custom cakes and cupcakes made with quality ingredients. They offer vegan and nut-free options and ship nationwide for wedding celebrations.

    $18/serving – $123/serving

    Retail cake and cupcake pricing; per-serving range suggests individual/non-wedding items rather than wedding cake service.

    modernhealth-consciousminimalistartisanal
    almsandfare.com(904) 419-9709154 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA
  • Crème de la Cocoa

    St. Augustine

    Crème de la Cocoa is a St. Augustine-based bakery specializing in custom wedding cakes, groom's cakes, and dessert bars with delivery and setup services. They offer 19+ cake flavors, personalized designs, and complementary desserts like macarons and plated treats.

    $45 – $125

    Wedding cake pricing with stated starting price for 6-inch custom cake and half-sheet option; delivery and setup available separately.

    elegantcustomartisticsophisticated
    cremedelacocoa.com(904) 466-9499299 San Marco Avenue St. Augustine, FL, 32084 United States
  • Divine Desserts by Tamara

    Jacksonville

    Divine Desserts by Tamara specializes in handcrafted custom wedding cakes made from scratch using Swiss Meringue buttercream and detailed sugar flowers. Wedding cakes start at $700 for 60 guests with consultations and tastings available by appointment.

    from $700

    Wedding cake starting price given for 60 guests; final pricing varies by guest count, design complexity, and flavor.

    elegantromanticcustomartisanalluxury
    divinedessertbytamara.com+1 904 385 92104458 Marquette Ave, Jacksonville, FL, 32210
  • For Goodness Cake Jax

    Jacksonville

    For Goodness Cake Jax specializes in custom, sculptural wedding cakes and celebration cakes with modern, elegant designs and intricate handmade details. Starting at $1,000, their wedding cakes are fully bespoke edible artworks designed to complement your celebration.

    $1,000 – $4,000

    Wedding cake starting prices and tiered celebration/specialty cake options with budget range up to $4,000+.

    modernelegantsculpturalartisticintricatecustom
    forgoodnesscakejax.com(904) 437-88622732 Moorsfield Lane, Jacksonville, FL, 32225-4701
  • Honie Bee's

    Jacksonville

    Honie Bee's is a custom cake bakery in Jacksonville, Florida specializing in handcrafted wedding cakes and personalized dessert experiences. They offer fully customizable designs with family recipes and premium ingredients.

    from $449

    Wedding cake pricing available by custom order; Sweet Bar package starts at $449 for up to 25 guests; Hot Cakes Party is a non-wedding service.

    customelegantpersonalizedhandcraftedmodern
    honieb.com(904) 647-56148020 Moncrief Dinsmore Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32219, USA
  • Breakable Hearts LLC

    Yulee

    Breakable Hearts LLC is a Northern Florida cake and dessert bakery specializing in luxe wedding cakes, viral fruit illusions, macarons, and creative dessert options for weddings and events. They offer buttercream cakes from cutting cakes to 5-tier designs, plus a full range of dessert shooters, cakesicles, and specialty treats.

    Pricing on request
    elegantluxemoderncreativeupscale
    breakableheartsllc.com9047993330464073 State Rd 200 Unit 9, Yulee, FL, 32097
  • Cause Yum Cakes by Rickie

    Jacksonville

    Cause Yum Cakes by Rickie is a custom cake design business creating personalized wedding cakes with custom flavors, frostings, and designs. They offer a full range of wedding cake services including additional dessert treats like cupcakes and chocolate-covered items.

    Pricing on request
    custompersonalizedcreative
    tally.so(904) 894-14901622 Wofford Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32218, USA
  • Judy's Cakes

    Jacksonville

    Judy's Cakes specializes in custom, elegantly designed wedding cakes made with premium ingredients using traditional methods. Each cake is personally designed and decorated to perfection for your special event.

    Pricing on request
    elegantcustomclassicsophisticated
    judyscakesinc.com(904) 710-61298101 Old Kings Rd S, Jacksonville, FL 32217, USA
  • Nana Teresa's Bake Shop

    Fernandina Beach

    Nana Teresa's Bake Shop is a custom wedding cake bakery in Fernandina Beach, Florida, offering an extensive selection of cake flavors, fillings, and buttercream options for personalized wedding designs.

    Pricing on request
    nanateresa.com904277797713 N 3rd St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034, USA
  • Palms Cake Designers

    Jacksonville

    Palms Cake Designers is a custom cake design company in Jacksonville, FL specializing in artistic, made-to-order designer cakes for weddings and special events. Founded by artist Aldo Ricardo with 15+ years of cake design experience, they create everything from traditional cakes to elaborate cake sculptures.

    Pricing on request
    artisticcustomdesignersculpturalelegant
    palmscakedesigners.com(904) 436-51655462 John Reynolds Dr, Jacksonville, FL 32277, USA
  • Plant Pastry

    Jacksonville

    Plant Pastry is a vegan bakery specializing in custom wedding cakes made from scratch with clean, cruelty-free ingredients. They offer cake tastings, sample boxes, and personalized designs for weddings and special events in Jacksonville, Florida.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing available by request only; no published prices provided.

    semi-nakednakedombrevintagemoderncustom
    plantpastry.com(904) 341-3918San Jose Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32217, USA
  • Smallcakes Cupcakery & Creamery

    Jacksonville

    Smallcakes Cupcakery & Creamery is a Jacksonville-based custom cake and dessert bakery offering tiered wedding cakes, cupcakes, and gourmet treats with over 100 flavor options. They provide private cake tastings and specialize in traditional and non-traditional wedding desserts.

    Pricing on request

    Cake tasting packages only; no wedding cake pricing provided.

    modernelegantcontemporary
    smallcakesjax.com904518392013141 City Station Dr Jacksonville, FL, 32218 United States
  • Sweet Weddings

    St. Augustine

    Sweet Weddings Cakes specializes in custom-designed, luxury wedding cakes crafted with artistry and attention to detail for St. Augustine weddings. They create handcrafted cakes designed to be a centerpiece of your celebration, working closely with couples and local venues.

    Pricing on request
    elegantluxurycustomartisticrefined
    sweetweddings.com(904) 824-2420144 King St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA
Get your shortlist

Which of these 32 fit your budget?

Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.

Rank these for me