12 cake makers in Hagerstown, MD
We tracked down 34 possible cake makers around Hagerstown and Cumberland, Boonsboro, Frostburg, then checked each one against its own website. These are the 12 we could verify. Not a top ten, and not a paid directory.
3 of them (25%) publish their pricing. Those are listed first with the real numbers. The other 9 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.
Know a Hagerstown cake makerwe're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it.
Maryland wedding cake bakers typically charge $6 to $7 per serving, with the broader market ranging from $4 to $35 per serving. These figures reflect only the vendors who publish pricing online; premium and luxury bakers tend to require an inquiry instead, so the true market average is likely higher.
The Hagerstown cake makers list
Jennifer's Desserts
CumberlandJennifer's Desserts is a Cumberland-area bakery that creates custom wedding cakes with buttercream icing and a wide selection of cake and filling flavors. They offer wedding consultations, date reservations, and delivery options for local and nearby events.
from $5/servingWedding cake pricing at $4.50 per serving with 100-serving minimum.
custombuttercreamclassicromantictraditionalStone Werks Coffee + Sweets
BoonsboroStone Werks Coffee + Sweets is a Boonsboro, Maryland bakery that makes custom cakes to order, including wedding cakes ranging from cutting cakes and cupcakes to four-tier designs. They offer a $40 tasting that is credited toward the order and free delivery within 15 miles of the shop.
$7/serving – $9/servingWedding cake pricing by per-serving rate.
customhandmadecommunityrusticplayfulNothing Bundt Cakes
HagerstownNothing Bundt Cakes in Hagerstown is a retail bakery offering Bundt cakes, Bundtlets, and Bundtinis with signature cream cheese frosting, and it lists wedding cakes as an available product.
$21/serving – $70/servingSample cake prices are retail/non-wedding range; catering minimum of $75 is below wedding meal standards.
moderncelebratorythemeddecorateddessert-focusedCasimir Bakery
HagerstownCasimir Bakery is a Hagerstown, MD bakery offering custom cakes, cookies, and confections for weddings, bridal showers, and other celebrations. It is led by a classically trained pastry chef and serves Washington County and surrounding areas.
Pricing on requestOnly retail/individual item pricing provided; no wedding cake pricing available.
customclassiccomfortingcelebrationlocalchef-trainedMichele's Bakery and Sweet Shoppe
HagerstownMichele's Bakery and Sweet Shoppe is a Hagerstown, MD full-service bakery that offers wedding cakes, cupcakes, and custom dessert options with free consultations and tastings.
Pricing on requestRetail cake pricing for non-wedding items; no wedding-specific per-serving prices published.
customclassicfamily-styledecorativeallergy-friendlyMountain Flour Bakery
FrostburgMountain Flour Bakery is a local bakery in McHenry, MD that offers baked goods for everyday and special occasions. The website states that it specializes in wedding cakes, making it a relevant option for couples looking for a local cake vendor.
Pricing on requestlocaltraditionaloccasion-basedAJ's Cookie Jar - Cumberland MD
CumberlandAJ's Cookie Jar is a Cumberland, MD bakery specializing in French macarons and cookies, with dessert orders available for weddings, birthdays, showers, and business events.
Pricing on requestFrenchluxurydessert-focusedcustomgluten-free-friendlySweet Notes Bakery
HagerstownSweet Notes Bakery is a scratch-made bakery in Williamsport, MD that offers custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, and a large cheesecake selection. Couples can book a tasting to mix and match cake, filling, and frosting flavors for their event.
Pricing on requestcustomscratch-madeclassic-with-a-twistlocalcafeThe Royal Cakery
HagerstownThe Royal Cakery is a family-owned specialty cake shop in Hagerstown, MD, offering custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and pastries made from scratch. It creates custom designs for special occasions, including bridal shower cakes, and requires advance notice for custom orders.
Pricing on requestcustommade-from-scratchfamily-ownedelegantclassicspecialtySanders Cookie Jar Bakery
HagerstownA third-generation Hagerstown bakery that makes decorated cakes and special-occasion cakes from scratch, along with pies, breads, cookies, and other baked goods.
Pricing on requesttraditionalfull-line bakerycustom decorated cakesspecial occasionHagerstown Dutch Bakery
HagerstownHagerstown Dutch Bakery is a bakery inside Pennsylvania Dutch Market in Hagerstown, MD that sells freshly made baked goods, including cakes, pies, cookies, and cheesecakes.
Pricing on requestNo wedding cake pricing published; only a non-wedding retail cookie special is listed.
traditionalhomestylemarketfreshly madeSafron Bakery Cafe
HagerstownSafron Bakery & Cafe is a family-owned, Parisian-inspired bakery and cafe in Hagerstown, MD, offering cakes, pastries, breads, and cafe fare. It could be relevant for wedding cake or dessert needs, though the site does not explicitly describe wedding services.
Pricing on requestCake pricing is not publicly listed; only non-wedding café menu items are priced.
Parisian-inspiredfamily-ownedbakerycafeauthentic
Which of these 12 fit your budget?
Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.
Rank these for me