18 cake makers in Fayetteville, NC
We tracked down 67 possible cake makers around Fayetteville and Spring Lake, Pinehurst, Hope Mills, Sanford, then checked each one against its own website. These are the 18 we could verify. Not a top ten, and not a paid directory.
2 of them (11%) publish their pricing. Those are listed first with the real numbers. The other 16 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.
Know a Fayetteville cake makerwe're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it.
Wedding cake bakers in North Carolina typically charge $7 per serving, with the broader market ranging from $3 to $12 per serving. Because premium and luxury bakers rarely publish prices and instead require direct inquiry, the vendors reflected here skew toward the more affordable end, meaning the true market average is likely higher.
The Fayetteville cake makers list
Well-Bred Bakery & Cafe
Spring LakeWell-Bred Bakery & Café is an award-winning bakery in Weaverville, NC that offers whole cakes, pies, and dessert catering for events. They provide custom cake options with 72 hours' notice and serve the greater Asheville area.
from $5/servingRetail cake pricing by size with per-serving calculations; no wedding-specific packaging or pricing stated.
artisanallocally-sourcedgourmetmountain-casualKayla Renee Cakes
FayettevilleKayla Renee Cakes is a custom cake bakery in downtown Raeford, NC specializing in handcrafted wedding cakes with in-person tastings and delivery service. They offer a variety of cake flavors, frostings, and fillings with transparent tiered pricing.
$20 – $900Wedding cake pricing by tier; single-tier through five-tier cakes ranging $20–$900.
artisanalmoderncustomizableInstagram-worthydetail-orientedCinnaholic
FayettevilleCinnaholic is a vegan bakery specializing in create-your-own cinnamon rolls and fresh-baked sweet treats, all dairy-free and egg-free. They explicitly cater weddings of all sizes.
Pricing on requestmoderncasualvegancreativecustomizableThe Bakehouse
PinehurstThe Bakehouse is a sixth-generation family-owned bakery in Aberdeen, NC that specializes in custom wedding cakes created to represent each couple's personal style. They offer scratch-made cakes that keep up with current trends while accommodating personalized touches.
Pricing on requestcustomartisanEuropeanclassictrend-focusedWant Some Cake
FayettevilleWant Some Cake LLC is a custom cake and dessert bakery in Raeford, NC, specializing in custom cakes, cupcakes, pound cakes, and dessert tables for events. They offer an extensive menu of classic, specialty, and gourmet cake flavors with customization options.
Pricing on requestcustomclassicgourmetCold Stone Creamery
Spring LakeCold Stone Creamery specializes in handcrafted ice cream cakes and catering for weddings, bridal showers, and events. They offer customizable ice cream cakes, sundae bars, and cupcakes perfect for wedding celebrations.
Pricing on requestmoderncasualfuncontemporaryMs. Ruthie's Doing It Bakery Boutique and Tea Shop
Hope MillsMs. Ruthie's Doing It is a bakery boutique specializing in custom cakes, cupcakes, and desserts with religious inspiration and Southern charm. They offer a rotating bi-monthly menu with customizable cake flavors and designs suitable for wedding celebrations.
Pricing on requestRetail cake and cupcake pricing with no wedding-specific packages or per-serving rates published.
eleganttraditionalSoutherncustommodernboutiqueNothing Bundt Cakes
FayettevilleNothing Bundt Cakes is a bakery specializing in Bundt cakes in various sizes, offering wedding cakes and catering services for ceremonies, receptions, and wedding-related events. They provide customizable flavors and decorations with delivery available up to 20 miles.
Pricing on requestelegantcustomizablemodernsweetNothing Bundt Cakes
PinehurstNothing Bundt Cakes specializes in handcrafted Bundt cakes available in multiple sizes with customizable flavors and designs, suitable for weddings and related events. They offer catering services with delivery up to 20 miles and can be customized for engagement parties, bridal showers, rehearsal dinners, and wedding day celebrations.
Pricing on requesthandcraftedcustomizableelegantmodernSuga Mamas Confections
FayettevilleSuga Mamas Confections is a confectionery business based in Fayetteville, NC that creates custom sweets and treats. The business is highly rated but currently in a transitional phase with limited online information available.
Pricing on requestCatherine Ann’s Filipino American Grill and Sweets
SanfordCatherine Ann's is a family-owned bakery and quick-service restaurant in Sanford, NC that specializes in handmade cookies, personalized cookie cakes, cupcakes, and homemade ice cream made fresh daily. They offer pre-order options for cakes and cupcakes for all occasions and can accommodate special requests.
Pricing on requestcasualhomemadefamily-friendlylocalcomfort-focusedCold Stone Creamery
PinehurstCold Stone Creamery offers handcrafted ice cream cakes and catering services for weddings, bridal showers, and special events. They specialize in customizable super-premium ice cream cakes with signature flavors or personalized selections.
Pricing on requestCold Stone Creamery
FayettevilleCold Stone Creamery offers custom ice cream cakes and catering for weddings, bridal showers, and other events. Their handcrafted ice cream cakes can be customized with various flavors, cake types, and mix-ins.
Pricing on requestFrom Scratch: The Rolling Cafe
FayettevilleFrom Scratch: The Rolling Cafe is a home-based artisan bakery specializing in custom cakes and handcrafted desserts made entirely from scratch using traditional baking methods. They offer custom cake designs, cupcakes, cookies, brownies, and pastries for special occasions including weddings.
Pricing on requestartisanhandcraftedtraditionalfreshcustomG. Charles Bakery
PinehurstG. Charles Bakery is a full-service bakery in Aberdeen, NC that specializes in custom cakes, desserts, and catering for special events including weddings. They offer custom cake designs and specialty baked goods for celebrations.
Pricing on requestSmallcakes: Cupcakery & Creamery
FayettevilleSmallcakes Fayetteville is a cupcakery and creamery offering custom wedding cakes and cupcakes baked fresh daily. They specialize in gourmet cupcakes, homemade ice cream, and custom orders for special occasions.
Pricing on requestcasualartisanalgourmetmodernLowes Foods of Southern Pines
PinehurstLowes Foods of Southern Pines is a full-service grocery store chain with an in-house bakery called The Cakery that offers custom cakes for special occasions. While primarily a supermarket, they provide cake and dessert options suitable for weddings.
Pricing on requestcasualaccessiblelocalhomestyleMillie's Mama Bakes
SanfordMillie's Mama Bakes is a gourmet cookie shop in downtown Sanford, NC that specializes in custom-themed cookies, cookie cakes, and other desserts suitable for events and celebrations.
Pricing on requestgourmetartisanalcustomthemed
Which of these 18 fit your budget?
Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.
Rank these for me